SOCIO-PSYCHOLOGICAL DIMENSIONS OF THE RUSSIAN-UKRAINIAN WAR: CULTURAL MEMORY, NATIONAL RESENTMENT, AND CYCLIC VIOLENCE


DOI: https://doi.org/10.17721/2520-2626/2025.36.7

Roman DODONOV

Abstract


The article is devoted to the analysis of cultural-historical and socio-psychological factors that led to the Russian-Ukrainian war. On the basis of the concept of cyclical violence, the role of cultural memory in substantiating “national resentment” is revealed. The dynamics of ideas about the essence of cultural memory and the content of memory wars in modern Russian-Ukrainian relations is traced. The Ukrainian studies approach to the problem of the extreme aggravation of Russian-Ukrainian relations involves considering the events after February 24, 2022, only as another episode of a longer historical confrontation of Ukraine with the expansionist desire of the Russians to assimilate Ukrainians as a nation, deprive them of their statehood and dissolve them in the imperial space. Other episodes of this everlasting struggle are the OUN-UPA raids, the liberation struggles of the Ukrainian people in 1917–1921, in particular, the proclamation of the Ukrainian National Republic, Kruty, the Ukrainian State of Skoropadskyi, the Directory, and even earlier – the Ems Ukaz (decree), the Valuev Circular, the destruction of Sich, Baturyn and Chyhyryn, Ruin, when the Russian tsar violated the terms of the Pereiaslav agreement and began the assimilation of Ukrainians. Every time the confrontation reaches a "hot phase", Ukrainians' cultural memory revives the images of the national heroes of the past. The content of cultural memory, mental traumas of previous wars, in particular World War II, and the national ressentiment of Russians fuel relapses of violence subject to cyclical patterns. The irrational combination of pictures from different historical periods, aimed at demonising Ukrainian soldiers, masks the true motives of the Russians. The pseudo-image of Ukraine, which seems to have betrayed the memory of grandfathers who gave their lives for the freedom and independence of the Soviet Motherland, is largely constructed by Putin's propaganda and does not actually reflect the vital and urgent needs of citizens of the 21st century. However, it performs an important mobilisation function and is capable of quickly turning on holy anger in a “heated” society.

Keywords


Ukraine; culture; social psychology; cultural memory; national resentment; commemorative practices; memory wars; concept of cyclical violence

References


Dworkin I. (2023). Pamiat pro Druhu svitovu viinu v umovakh rosiisko-ukrainskoi viiny: postanovka problemy [Memory of the Second World War in the Conditions of the Russian-Ukrainian War: Statement of the Problem]. Ukrainoznavchii almanakh, Issue 31. Pp. 24–28. (in Ukr.).

Dodonov R. (2016). Skhidnoukrainskyi konflikt v konteksti kontseptsii tsyklichnoho nasyllia [Eastern Ukrainian Conflict in the Context of the Concept of Cyclical Violence]. Skhidnoukrainskyi konflikt v konteksti hlobalnykh transformatsii. Zbirnyk statei. Issue 2. Pр.51–64. (in Ukr.).

Zashkilniak L. (2006-2007). Istorychna pamiat ta istoriohrafiia yak doslidnytske pole dlia intelektualnoi istorii [Historical Memory and Historiography as a Research Field for Intellectual History]. Ukraina: kulturna spadshchyna, natsionalna svidomist, derzhavnist. № 15. Рp. 855–862. (in Ukr.).

Nikiliev O. (2023). Istorychni koreni ta peredumovy rosiisko-ukrainskoi viiny: mentalnyi vymir [Historical Roots and Prerequisites of the Russian-Ukrainian War: the Mental Dimension]. Hrani. Vol. 26, №. 5. Рp. 110–117. (in Ukr.).

Tyshkov V. (2001). Obshchestvo v vooruzhennom konflykte (эtnohrafyia chechenskoi voiny) [Society in Armed Conflict (Ethnography of the Chechen War)]. Moscow. 534 p. (in Rus.).

Tsybenko M.O. (2024). Buttievi modusy kolektyvnoi pamiati ta yii symvolichni reprezentatsii [Essential modes of collective memory and its symbolic representations]. Dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, speciality 033 Philosophy. Cherkasy State Technological University, Cherkasy. 228 р. (in Ukr.).

Shtokvysh O., Korolenko B. (2015). «Krymska obraza»: mif, yoho instrumentalizatsiia ta heopolitychni proektsii [“Crimean offense”: Myth, its Instrumentalization and Geopolitical Projections]. Skhidnoukrainskyi konflikt v konteksti hlobalnykh transformatsii. Zbirnyk statei. Vol. 1. Рp. 341–351. (in Ukr.).

Yak kreml zminiuvav tsili viiny proty Ukrainy [How the Kremlin changed the goals of the war against Ukraine]. (2024). Tsentr protydii dezinformatsii pry RNBO Ukrainy. URL: https://cpd.gov.ua/main/yak-kreml-zminyuvav-czili-vijny-proty-ukrayiny/ (in Ukr.).

Yakushko O. (2023). Psykhoanaliz i viina: istoriia osmyslennia, podolannia ta pidtrymky voiennoho nasylstva [Psychoanalysis and War: A History of Understanding, Coping, and Sustaining War Violence]. Ukrainskyi psykhoanalitychnyi zhurnal. Vol. 1, # 1. Pp. 14–20. URL: https://doi.org/10.32782/upj/2023-1-3 (in Ukr.).

Assman J. (2011). Cultural Memory and Early Civilization: Writing, Remembrance, and Political Imagination. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 319 p.

Kaldor M. (2012). New and Old Wars: Organized Violence in a Global Era (3rd ed). Cambridge: Polity Press, 268 p.

Lumsden M. (1997). Focus On: Breaking the Cycle of Violence. Journal of Peace Research. 34 (4). Pp. 377–383.

Reshetnikov M. (2022). Methodological Approaches to the Psychological Analysis of Ethnic Conflicts and Ideas of Anti-Russism. In: D. B. Bogoyavlenskaya (ed.). From Roots to Modernity: Conference Proceedings on the 130 Year Anniversary of Moscow Psychological Society. Moscow: Moscow Psychological Society. Pp. 107–110.

Rohrbaugh J. B. (2006). Domestic Violence in Same-Gender Relationships. Family Court Review. Vol. 44, # 2. Pp. 287–299.

Straus M.A. (2010). Thirty Years of Denying Evidence on Gender Symmetry in Partner Violence: Implications for Prevention and Treatment. Partner Abuse. Vol. 1, # 3. 332 p.

van Wormer K. (2009). Restorative Justice as Social Justice for Victims of Gendered Violence: A Standpoint Feminist Perspective. Social Work. Vol. 54, # 2. Pp. 107–115.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.